In this review, The Critical Drinker delivers a harsh critique of the Supergirl film, labeling it a "cinematic calamity" and a "tedious mess" (0:26-0:47). The review covers several key criticisms regarding the film's production and narrative:
- Weak Narrative and Writing: The plot is described as a collection of convenient coincidences rather than a cohesive story, featuring generic characters, unearned character arcs, and dialogue filled with "cringe" meta-humor (3:45-4:15).
- Characterization Issues: The protagonist, Kara, is criticized for being portrayed as a cynical, unlikable anti-hero, a choice the reviewer feels is unearned given her youth and lack of development (6:05-7:25).
- Technical Flaws: The reviewer calls out poor cinematography, lifeless action sequences, and the inclusion of unnecessary cameos—such as Lobo (played by Jason Momoa)—which he believes adds nothing to the story (0:47-1:24, 4:39-4:56).
- Behind the Scenes: The Critical Drinker questions the decision to hire screenwriter Anna Naggera, arguing that her limited experience was a factor in the film's poor execution (5:21-5:55).
Ultimately, the reviewer concludes that the film is a "depressingly bleak" and uninspired entry in a cinematic universe that he feels is already struggling to maintain relevance (7:53-8:29).